IELTS Free Online Writing Practice - Cultural appropriation is an ongoing debate in contemporary society. Discuss the impact of cultural appropriation on identity mation, both positively and negatively.
IELTS.WORK Free Online Writing Practice # 1711086337
Writing Task 2 Topic:"Cultural appropriation is an ongoing debate in contemporary society. Discuss the impact of cultural appropriation on identity formation, both positively and negatively."
Model Answer:
The concept of cultural appropriation has become a central issue in discussions around identity formation. On one hand, cultural appropriation can have a positive impact on personal identity by encouraging self-expression and promoting understanding between different cultures. On the other hand, it can also lead to negative consequences such as misappropriation and exploitation of marginalized groups' cultural heritage. In this essay, I will analyze the dual effects of cultural appropriation on identity formation from both perspectives.
Cultural appropriation occurs when a person, especially someone from the dominant culture, adopts elements from another culture without a proper understanding of its significance or respect for its context. This phenomenon has led to numerous controversies and debates. However, it is essential to recognize that not all instances of cultural exchange are negative; sometimes, it can lead to positive outcomes in terms of personal identity formation. For instance, when an individual from one culture learns about and embraces elements from another culture, it may result in a deeper sense of self-awareness and acceptance of their unique identity. This process can also foster empathy, understanding, and tolerance among different cultures.
Nevertheless, the negative impacts of cultural appropriation on identity formation are more pronounced when considering how marginalized groups' cultural heritage is often misused or exploited. When dominant cultures adopt specific elements from minority cultures without respecting their historical and social significance, it can result in a form of cultural erasure. This can be particularly damaging to the self-identity of those belonging to the appropriated culture, as they may feel that their unique heritage is being commodified or trivialised.
Furthermore, cultural appropriation can also lead to stereotyping and perpetuation of harmful stereotypes about certain cultures. For example, when elements from a specific culture are taken out of context and used for fashion trends or entertainment purposes without proper understanding, it may reinforce negative perceptions and prejudices against that culture. In turn, this can impact the self-identity of individuals belonging to that cultural group, as they might feel pressured to conform to these stereotypes or face discrimination due to their cultural background.
In conclusion, while cultural appropriation can have some positive impacts on identity formation by encouraging self-expression and promoting cross-cultural understanding, it is crucial to recognize the potential negative consequences of misappropriation and exploitation of marginalized groups' cultural heritage. As an editor preparing IELTS writing test questions, it is essential to ensure that these complexities are accurately reflected in the question's structure and tone, while also providing ample opportunities for candidates to express their views comprehensively and coherently.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Scoring:
- Task Response (40%): The candidate addresses all parts of the question and provides a comprehensive response.
- Coherence and Cohesion (30%): The candidate's answer is logically structured, with clear and smooth transitions between ideas.
- Lexical Resource (20%): The candidate uses a wide range of vocabulary, including less common or more specialized words when appropriate.
- Grammatical Range and Accuracy (10%): The candidate demonstrates a wide range of grammar structures with few errors in tense, agreement, etc.
Source:
https://ielts.work/?id=1711086337&page=ielts-writing-practice
For more:
https://ielts.work/?page=ielts-writing-practice
